Skip to main content

Week 5 Thoughts

Giroux has a great rebuttal for Todd Gitlin’s critique of social movements organized around gender, race, sexual orientation, multiculturalism that, according to Gatlin, overlook the more ‘real politics’ of economic inequality and class. Giroux uses Hall’s insight that class is lived through the modalities of race and gender to show how social movements organized around racial and gendered issues expose how these issues are connected to class-based politics (example: the social movement ACT UP, which tried to make AIDS visible, exposed how AIDS was taking its greatest toll on poor black women). My question is, can we think of social movements that are seemingly organized around class issues, but which also expose how race and gender are tied up in class politics. As I am writing this, I am thinking of Matthew Desmond’s book Evicted: Poverty and Profit in the American City, a study of how eight families in Milwaukee struggled with poverty and home insecurity. Although the families are all struggling, Desmond points out how their experiences are lived through the modalities of race and gender. For example, he points out that poor black women are more likely to get evicted. He also points out how white landlords are more willing to overlook crime records of white people than of black people.

How do Peter N. Kiang’s practices as an instructor and fellow coworker in the College of Education reflect Giroux’s theory of critical public pedagogy? How might Gitlin and others’ critique of cultural politics be compared to the arguments made by the core of students opposing Kiang’s teaching methods?

-Daisy 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

On Journals and Prose

My two questions from this week have emerged from the Judith Butler piece, A 'Bad Writer' Bites Back , both centered around the journal, Philosophy and Literature —which Butler describes as the self-proclaimed “arbiter of good prose.”  I agree with Butler’s staunch defense of questioning common sense and provoking “new ways of looking at a familiar world”, and was reminded of David Harvey’s quote in the introduction to his Companion to Marx’s Capital : “Real learning always entails a struggle to understand the unknown.”   Butler describes Philosophy and Literature as a “culturally conservative academic journal” which naturally led me down a longer-than-anticipated visit to the journal's website . I was greeted with a video presented by the Philosophy and Literature’s editor Garry L. Hagberg, who rails against the “jargon infested” work that litters the journal’s field, locating Philosophy and Literature in clear opposition to such bothersome clutter.  However, Hagberg...
Post a Comment
Read more

Articulation_by_Abby Escatel

 In "Race, Articulation and Societies Structured in Dominance," Stuart Hall is concerned with complicating Marxist theory's tendency to overgeneralize and universalize its claims that are specifically located within a European history of labor. Questions concerning slavery, coloniality, unfree/forced labor come to the fore and force Marxist theorists to grapple with the need to be specific in their contextualization and historicization of particular moments, ruptures and conjunctures. My questions are as follows:  1. How do we move forward with Marxism while taking into account the component of "unfreedom" when conceptualizing class, labor, and labor power? How does the "proletariat" fail to account for the lived realities of racialized bodies?  2. It seems as though Hall is also saying that race is not all encompassing and also shouldn't be overgeneralized/universalized. In short, labor and race are both always already at work. As a scholar who ce...
Post a Comment
Read more

Week 5

  What are the differences between Gramsci’s concept of the “organic intellectual” and Hall’s “public pedagogy?”   On the topic of the diasporic intellectual, Kuan-Hsing Chen mentions that “Some of the diasporic intellectuals I know of have exercised their power, for better or worse, back home, but you have not. And some of them are trying to move back, in whatever way. So, in that sense, you are very peculiar” (503). Although Hall felt some reconnection with the Carribean through the Black diasporic population in Britain, he insists that cultural identity is not fixed but “comes out of very specific historical formations, out of very specific histories and cultural repertoires of enunciation, that it can constitute a ‘positionality’, which we call, provisionally, identity” (503). Individuals can negotiate, rearticulate, recontextualize their different identities, but how does this rearticulation work at an institutional-level?   Thelma
Post a Comment
Read more